Verse 18.16
तत्रैवं सति कर्तारमात्मानं केवलं तु यः।पश्यत्यकृतबुद्धित्वान्न स पश्यति दुर्मतिः॥
tatraivaṃ sati kartāramātmānaṃ kevalaṃ tu yaḥpaśyatyakṛtabuddhitvānna sa paśyati durmatiḥ
Meaning
That being so, whoever sees himself alone as the doer, because his understanding is untrained, does not see at all; his thinking is muddled.
ऐसा होते हुए भी जो केवल अपने को ही करने वाला मानता है, वह अपनी कच्ची समझ के कारण ठीक से देखता ही नहीं; उसकी बुद्धि उलझी हुई है।
Word by word
- तत्र
- in that matter
- एवम्
- thus
- सति
- being so
- कर्तारम्
- as the doer
- आत्मानम्
- himself
- केवलम्
- alone
- तु
- but
- यः
- whoever
- पश्यति
- sees
- अकृतबुद्धित्वात्
- from untrained understanding
- न
- not
- सः
- he
- पश्यति
- sees
- दुर्मतिः
- muddled in mind
Context
Krishna has just named five things behind every action: the body, the doer, the senses, their many efforts, and a fifth that no one controls, called daiva. Here he draws the conclusion; some commentators read ‘alone’ as the pure Self, which does nothing, being mistaken for the doer.
Explanation
A girl in your lane tops her board exams, and the banner at the corner carries only her photo. Behind that photo are her mother’s 5 am tea, a teacher’s extra class, an elder cousin’s old notes, and a question paper that happened to suit her. Krishna has just counted five causes behind any act. To look at all that and still say ‘I alone did it’ is, he says, simply not seeing. The hard work was real; it was one part of five.
In life
Personal
When a plan you made falls apart and you lie awake telling yourself it was entirely your fault.
Try todayOn a sheet of paper, list five things that had a hand in it, such as timing, the weather or other people. Then circle only the one that was truly in your hands.
Family & society
When guests praise the dinner and you say ‘I made it all’, while your sister-in-law, who has been chopping since noon, stands right behind you.
Try todayTonight, tell one person at home, by name, the one thing they did that made your day’s work possible.
Work
When your shop has its best month ever and you tell everyone it is down to your own sharp head.
Try todayWrite the names of three people without whom this month would not have happened. Tell one of them so before you pull the shutter down today.
Reflect
Think of the thing you are proudest of: whose hands, other than yours, are in it?
This verse is in the film · 18.16–18.17Who thinks 'I alone did this'Since five causes are at work, Krishna says the person who sees himself as the only doer does not see things as they are. And the one who has no sense of 'I did it', whose understanding is not clouded, is not bound even if he kills in this war. What ties a person to an action, the verses say, is the 'I' he puts into it.